Watercooler Confessions
Picture this:
The meeting has just ended. The leader left feeling confident that everyone is on the same page. But two minutes later, the real conversations begin—at the watercooler, in Slack DMs, or on the walk to the parking lot.
It's Friday afternoon, and the energy in the office is winding down. Sarah leans over to Emily by the water cooler. "Did you hear what John said in the meeting today? About the new marketing plan? Totally unrealistic!" she whispers. Emily nods sympathetically, "Right? I can't believe they expect us to pull that off with this deadline."
This scene, a classic "watercooler confession," highlights a symptom of a deeper problem: misalignment within a team. Team members feel more comfortable venting their frustrations with colleagues than voicing them directly during meetings.
This is where the masks come off and unfiltered opinions are shared. People vent frustrations, criticize ideas they didn’t challenge in the meeting, and strategize ways to work around decisions they didn’t agree with.
Sound familiar?
The Meeting After the Meeting
Another classic sign of misalignment is what I like to call “the meeting after the meeting. ”The meeting ends, everyone packs up their laptops, and a sense of relief washes over the room. But as people head out, conversations erupt in the hallways and by the coffee machine. This happens when people don’t feel comfortable being honest in the room. Whether it’s fear of retaliation, lack of trust, or simply the perception that their input doesn’t matter, the result is the same: people retreat to side conversations where the real feedback is shared.
At the heart of these issues is a lack of psychological safety. This is the belief that you won’t be punished or humiliated for speaking up with ideas, questions, concerns, or mistakes. Without it, teams operate in survival mode, avoiding conflict and withholding their best thinking.
The Cost of Misalignment
Misalignment isn’t just a “people problem.” It’s a performance problem. When teams aren’t aligned:
Communication breaks down.
Execution slows to a crawl.
Revenue and opportunities are left on the tab
I read a recent article from The Predictive Index which reported that strategic disagreement can cost a company up to 25% of its revenue.
Here’s the hard truth: the leader has the culture they set—or the culture they allow to take shape.
Action Steps for Leaders
If you’re ready to break the cycle of misalignment, here’s where to start:
Get Curious: Listen to your team. What are they not saying in the meeting? Ask questions that uncover root issues.
Cultivate Safety: Model honesty and invite feedback. Show your team it’s safe to disagree respectfully.
Invest in Alignment: Tools like The 5 Voices can help create clarity and trust.
Investing in building a culture of trust, open communication, and psychological safety is an investment in your team's success and your company's bottom line. Leadership isn’t about perfection. It’s about progress. And the good news? The culture you dream of starts with one simple step: deciding to lead with intention.
Here’s to building healthy teams that thrive, together.
Anytime You Are Ready...
Whenever you’re ready to take the next step, here are a few ways I can help you:
👉 Subscribe to my weekly newsletter for leadership insights delivered right to your inbox.
👉 Book a coaching session to dive deeper into your team’s unique challenges and opportunities.
👉 Explore leadership resources to sharpen your skills and grow your impact.
Get curious is couch a helpful step!